diff --git a/app/lib/account_statuses_filter.rb b/app/lib/account_statuses_filter.rb
index cfc9be96608..db1c3df7763 100644
--- a/app/lib/account_statuses_filter.rb
+++ b/app/lib/account_statuses_filter.rb
@@ -48,12 +48,20 @@ class AccountStatusesFilter
   def filtered_scope
     scope = account.statuses.left_outer_joins(:mentions)
 
-    scope.merge!(scope.where(visibility: follower? ? %i(public unlisted private) : %i(public unlisted)).or(scope.where(mentions: { account_id: current_account.id })).group(Status.arel_table[:id]))
+    scope.merge!(visibility_scope(scope).or(scope.where(mentions: { account_id: current_account.id })).group(Status.arel_table[:id]))
     scope.merge!(filtered_reblogs_scope) if reblogs_may_occur?
 
     scope
   end
 
+  def visibility_scope(scope)
+    if follower?
+      scope.list_eligible_visibility
+    else
+      scope.distributable_visibility
+    end
+  end
+
   def filtered_reblogs_scope
     scope = Status.left_outer_joins(reblog: :account)
     scope
diff --git a/app/services/report_service.rb b/app/services/report_service.rb
index c95e216c790..40749c807fd 100644
--- a/app/services/report_service.rb
+++ b/app/services/report_service.rb
@@ -82,15 +82,24 @@ class ReportService < BaseService
     return AccountStatusesFilter.new(@target_account, @source_account).results.with_discarded.find(Array(@status_ids)).pluck(:id) if @source_account.local?
 
     # If the account making reports is remote, it is likely anonymized so we have to relax the requirements for attaching statuses.
-    domain = @source_account.domain.to_s.downcase
-    has_followers = @target_account.followers.with_domain(domain).exists?
-    visibility = has_followers ? %i(public unlisted private) : %i(public unlisted)
     scope = @target_account.statuses.with_discarded
-    scope.merge!(scope.where(visibility: visibility).or(scope.where('EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM mentions m JOIN accounts a ON m.account_id = a.id WHERE lower(a.domain) = ?)', domain)))
+    scope.merge!(visibility_scope(scope).or(scope.where('EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM mentions m JOIN accounts a ON m.account_id = a.id WHERE lower(a.domain) = ?)', @source_account.domain.to_s.downcase)))
     # Allow missing posts to not drop reports that include e.g. a deleted post
     scope.where(id: Array(@status_ids)).pluck(:id)
   end
 
+  def visibility_scope(scope)
+    if target_has_source_domain_followers?
+      scope.list_eligible_visibility
+    else
+      scope.distributable_visibility
+    end
+  end
+
+  def target_has_source_domain_followers?
+    @target_account.followers.with_domain(@source_account.domain).exists?
+  end
+
   def payload
     Oj.dump(serialize_payload(@report, ActivityPub::FlagSerializer, account: some_local_account))
   end